Sell Coins (We Buy Gold, Silver & Rare Coins)
Sell Coins in Boise – Boise Coin Buyers
Boise Coin Buyers is the trusted choice for anyone looking to sell coins in Boise, Idaho. Whether you have gold coins, silver dollars, or an inherited collection of rare coins, we provide accurate valuations and fair cash offers. Our team of numismatic professionals has decades of combined experience assessing coins of all kinds—from U.S. Mint issues to world currency and historical artifacts.
Our shop is conveniently located for Boise residents, just minutes from downtown and easily accessible from neighborhoods like North End, Bench, and Harris Ranch. When you step into Boise Coin Buyers, you can expect complete transparency, respectful service, and expert guidance on every transaction.
Let’s make the process simple. Bring your coins for a free appraisal, receive an honest offer, and walk out with cash in hand. Whether you’re decluttering, liquidating an estate, or selling for investment reasons, Boise Coin Buyers ensures you get the best return possible.
Why Sell Your Coins to Us?
Selling coins can feel overwhelming if you’re unsure of their worth. Many people inherit collections and have no idea which pieces are valuable. That’s where Boise Coin Buyers stands out.
1. Expert Appraisers Who Know the Market
Our coin specialists are trained in both historical and modern valuation methods. We use the latest price guides, auction records, and live market data to give you an accurate assessment. You’ll always know exactly how your offer is calculated.
2. Local Reputation You Can Trust
We’ve built strong relationships in Boise and across the Treasure Valley through consistent integrity. Many of our clients are repeat customers or referrals from others who had great experiences selling with us.
3. Instant Cash Payments
You won’t have to wait weeks for a payout. Once we evaluate and agree on a price, we pay you immediately—either in cash or by secure digital transfer if you prefer.
4. Free, No-Obligation Appraisals
Our appraisals are 100% free. You can walk in, get your coins evaluated, and leave without any pressure to sell. We want you to feel confident and informed before making any decision.
5. Competitive Offers Based on Real Market Trends
Our offers reflect current gold and silver prices, collector demand, and rarity. Because we buy and sell daily, we always know where the market stands.
Here’s why that matters. Coin values fluctuate just like any other investment asset. By selling to experts who follow the market closely, you avoid underpricing your coins or waiting too long during a market dip.
What Types of Coins Do We Buy?
Boise Coin Buyers purchases virtually every category of coin, from everyday bullion to one-of-a-kind historical pieces. Here’s a breakdown of the main types we accept:
Gold Coins
We buy all forms of gold coins, including:
American Gold Eagles and Gold Buffalos
Canadian Maple Leafs
Krugerrands
Pre-1933 U.S. gold coins such as Liberty Head and Saint-Gaudens Double Eagles
Foreign gold coins from Europe, Asia, and Latin America
Even damaged or jewelry-mounted coins may still hold significant melt or collectible value.
Silver Coins
Silver coins are among the most common we see. Bring in:
Morgan and Peace Dollars
Walking Liberty Half Dollars
Mercury Dimes
Silver Eagles
Foreign silver coins and commemoratives
We buy them individually or by the roll, tube, or bag. If your coins are 90% silver “junk silver,” we’ll calculate their melt value based on live silver spot prices.
Rare and Collectible Coins
If you have coins that are older, limited edition, or mint errors, we’re particularly interested. Examples include:
Key-date Lincoln cents
Buffalo nickels
Early U.S. mint issues (pre-1900)
Carson City mint marks (CC)
Foreign coins from the 1800s or earlier
Our numismatic team loves evaluating historical pieces and explaining what makes them valuable.
Bullion Rounds and Bars
We also buy bullion items such as:
Silver rounds (1 oz, 5 oz, 10 oz)
Gold bars and ingots
Platinum or palladium coins and bars
These are priced according to current spot rates plus premiums for recognized refiners like PAMP Suisse or Engelhard.
Proof and Mint Sets
If you’ve collected U.S. Mint proof sets or uncirculated mint sets, we buy both modern and vintage series. Some older proof sets—especially from the 1950s and 1960s—can carry strong premiums.
Foreign Currency and Tokens
We also buy world coins, military tokens, and early trade currency. Many foreign coins contain silver or gold content that adds intrinsic value beyond face denomination.
Factors That Determine the Value of Your Coins
Let’s break down what really affects a coin’s value. Understanding these factors can help you make smarter selling decisions.
1. Metal Content
Gold, silver, and platinum coins derive a portion of their value from metal weight. This “melt value” fluctuates with global market prices. When precious metal prices rise, so does your payout.
2. Rarity
Coins with limited mintage, historical errors, or low surviving populations tend to command higher prices. For instance, a 1909-S VDB Lincoln cent is worth far more than a common 1970s penny.
3. Condition (Grading)
Professional grading plays a huge role in pricing. The Sheldon scale ranks coins from Poor (P-1) to Perfect Mint State (MS-70). Even one grade difference can double or triple value. Boise Coin Buyers can evaluate coins on-site and explain grading distinctions clearly.
4. Collector Demand
Some coins remain popular with collectors regardless of metal content. For example, Carson City Morgan Dollars or key-date silver quarters often sell above melt value due to demand among hobbyists.
5. Historical Significance
Coins tied to notable events—such as the California Gold Rush or World War II—carry strong collector appeal. Commemoratives and limited runs can appreciate with time.
6. Authenticity and Certification
Certified coins from grading services like PCGS or NGC typically sell for more. If your coin is already slabbed (encased in a protective holder), bring it in as is. We also verify authenticity for raw coins to ensure fair pricing.
7. Market Timing
Finally, market timing matters. Precious metal prices fluctuate daily. If gold or silver spikes, selling during that window can yield a higher payout. Boise Coin Buyers tracks market movements in real time, so your appraisal reflects the most current values.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need an appointment to sell my coins?
No. Walk-ins are always welcome. However, if you’re bringing a large collection or estate, we recommend calling ahead so we can set aside sufficient time for your evaluation.
How do you determine a coin’s price?
We base our offers on live market data, coin condition, rarity, and demand. Each appraisal includes a full explanation of how we arrived at the number. We aim for total transparency so you can sell with confidence.
Do you buy damaged or cleaned coins?
Yes. Even if a coin has scratches, tarnish, or cleaning marks, it may still hold intrinsic or collector value. Our appraisers evaluate every coin individually to ensure you get a fair offer.
Can you come to my home to appraise a collection?
Yes. For larger or more valuable collections, we offer private in-home appraisals across Boise and surrounding areas, including Meridian, Eagle, and Nampa. These appointments are discreet, secure, and handled by our most experienced staff.
What if I’m not ready to sell yet?
No problem. Many clients simply want to understand the current market value of their collection. Our free appraisals give you clarity so you can decide when the time is right.
Contact Us Today!
At Boise Coin Buyers, every appraisal starts with a single goal: to give you honest, data-backed information. Whether you sell today or simply learn what your collection is worth, our mission is to build lasting trust within the Boise community.
We don’t believe in gimmicks or high-pressure sales tactics. We believe in straightforward service, accurate evaluation, and fair offers. You deserve that level of respect when dealing with your valuables.
When you’re ready, come see us. Bring your gold coins, silver rounds, or inherited sets. Let’s uncover what your collection is really worth.